| Date | Opponent | Status | Result | Links |
| Aug. 31 | at Va. Wesleyan @ Newport News, Va. | Final | W, 5-1 | Box Score Box Score Recap |
| Sep. 2 | at Chris. Newport | Final | W, 2-1 | Box Score Box Score Recap |
| Christopher Newport Tournament | ||||
| Sep. 8 | McDaniel | Final | W, 3-1 | Box Score Box Score Recap |
| Holiday Inn Conference Center Soccer Classic - York, Pa. William Paterson vs. Susquehanna - 3:00 pm | ||||
| Sep. 9 | Susquehanna | Final | L, 1-0 | Box Score Box Score Recap |
| Holiday Inn Conference Center Soccer Classic Championship Game | ||||
| Sep. 12 | Alvernia | Final - 2OT | T, 0-0 | Box Score Box Score Recap |
| Sep. 15 | at Wesley * | Final | W, 4-1 | Box Score Box Score Recap |
| Sep. 17 | at Lycoming | Final | W, 2-1 | Box Score Box Score Recap |
| Sep. 19 | Johns Hopkins | Final | W, 1-0 | Box Score Box Score Recap |
| Sep. 22 | at Neumann | Final | W, 3-0 | Box Score Box Score Recap |
| Sep. 26 | at Messiah | Final - 2OT | L, 1-0 | Box Score Box Score Recap |
| Sep. 29 | Salisbury * | Final - 2OT | W, 2-1 | Box Score Box Score Recap |
| York later vacated the contest by NCAA ruling | ||||
| Oct. 3 | at Penn St.-Harrisburg | Final | W, 6-2 | Box Score Box Score Recap |
| York later vacated the contest by NCAA ruling | ||||
| Oct. 6 | Marymount (Va.) * | Final | W, 8-0 | Box Score Box Score Recap |
| York later vacated the contest by NCAA ruling | ||||
| Oct. 10 | Gettysburg | Final | W, 1-0 | Box Score Box Score Recap |
| Oct. 13 | at St. Mary's (Md.) * | Final | W, 4-0 | Box Score Box Score Recap |
| Oct. 17 | Frostburg St. * | Final | T, 1-1 | Box Score Box Score Recap |
| Oct. 20 | at Mary Washington * | Final | W, 1-0 | Box Score Box Score Recap |
| Oct. 24 | Manhattanville | Final | W, 3-0 | Box Score Box Score Recap |
| Oct. 27 | St. Mary's (Md.) | Final | W, 1-0 | Box Score Box Score Recap |
| CAC Tournament - First Round | ||||
| Nov. 1 | at Frostburg St. | Final - 2OT | W, 4-3 | Box Score Box Score Recap |
| CAC Tournament - Semifinals | ||||
| Nov. 3 | Mary Washington | Final | W, 5-0 | Box Score Box Score Recap |
| CAC Tournament - Championship Game | ||||
| Nov. 10 | St. Joseph's (L.I.) | Final | W, 1-0 | Box Score Box Score Recap |
| NCAA Tournament - First Round | ||||
| Nov. 11 | Rutgers-Camden | Final - PK Home | T, 0-0 | Box Score Box Score Recap |
| NCAA Tournament - Second Round | ||||
| Nov. 17 | at Messiah @ York College, York, PA | Final - PK Home | T, 2-2 | Box Score Box Score Recap |
| NCAA Tournament - Third Round | ||||
| Home games in bold. * = Conference games. | ||||